Florida Dishes: Where to Go for Key Lime Pie

Real Estate Blog

rss logo

RSS Feed Archives

2026 | 8 Posts
- February | 4 Posts
- January | 4 Posts
2025 | 48 Posts
- December | 4 Posts
- November | 4 Posts
- October | 4 Posts
- September | 4 Posts
- August | 4 Posts
- July | 4 Posts
- June | 4 Posts
- May | 4 Posts
- April | 4 Posts
- March | 4 Posts
- February | 4 Posts
- January | 4 Posts
2024 | 48 Posts
- December | 4 Posts
- November | 4 Posts
- October | 4 Posts
- September | 4 Posts
- August | 4 Posts
- July | 4 Posts
- June | 4 Posts
- May | 4 Posts
- April | 4 Posts
- March | 4 Posts
- February | 4 Posts
- January | 4 Posts
2023 | 48 Posts
- December | 4 Posts
- November | 4 Posts
- October | 4 Posts
- September | 4 Posts
- August | 4 Posts
- July | 4 Posts
- June | 4 Posts
- May | 4 Posts
- April | 4 Posts
- March | 4 Posts
- February | 4 Posts
- January | 4 Posts
2022 | 46 Posts
- December | 4 Posts
- November | 4 Posts
- October | 4 Posts
- September | 4 Posts
- August | 3 Posts
- July | 4 Posts
- June | 4 Posts
- May | 4 Posts
- April | 4 Posts
- March | 3 Posts
- February | 4 Posts
- January | 4 Posts
2021 | 46 Posts
- December | 4 Posts
- November | 4 Posts
- October | 3 Posts
- September | 4 Posts
- August | 4 Posts
- July | 4 Posts
- June | 4 Posts
- May | 3 Posts
- April | 4 Posts
- March | 4 Posts
- February | 5 Posts
- January | 3 Posts
2020 | 46 Posts
- December | 3 Posts
- November | 3 Posts
- October | 5 Posts
- September | 3 Posts
- August | 4 Posts
- July | 4 Posts
- June | 2 Posts
- May | 4 Posts
- April | 3 Posts
- March | 4 Posts
- February | 7 Posts
- January | 4 Posts
2019 | 31 Posts
- December | 4 Posts
- November | 5 Posts
- October | 3 Posts
- September | 4 Posts
- August | 6 Posts
- July | 4 Posts
- June | 4 Posts
- May | 1 Posts
2018 | 1 Posts
- April | 1 Posts
2017 | 9 Posts
- November | 1 Posts
- October | 4 Posts
- September | 2 Posts
- August | 2 Posts

Tags

wagner realty Buying a House Area Information Community events For Buyers Longboat Key Things to do Local amenities Restaurants Dining Sarasota, FL Luxury Homes Home buying Home buyer advice Holidays Bradenton FL Venice FL Siesta Key, FL Sarasota County Manatee County Holmes Beach FL Lakewood Ranch Family fun Anna Maria FL Bradenton, FL Outdoor Fun De-Clutter Your Home Moving Suggestions Charities Ellenton, FL Englewood, FL Donation Centers Lakewood Ranch, Florida Parrish, FL Outdoors and Recreation Local businesses Fishing Event Festivals Home improvement Holiday giving Tiny House Living Bakeries Gardens Selling Your Home Home Maintenance Pet Friendly Homes Retirees Home Buying Retirement Homeowners Home Design Homeownership Single Mom Kid & Parent Friendly Suburbs Staging a Home interior design staging Technology Apps Lifestyle Downsizing Decorating DIY Before Selling Home Bradenton Beach FL Clean Your Home REAL ESTATE MARKET Buying the Perfect Home Vacation Rentals Home Inspections Dream Home Bird Bay, Fl Bird Key, FL Siesta Key Holmes Beach, Fl Renovations Palmetto FL Real Estate Investment Lido Beach, Fl REAL ESTATE AGENTS Hire a Realtor! Home Selling Home selling advice Home Selling Tips Press Release relocate New Neighborhood Curb Appeal Move venice First Time Homebuyers Energy Efficient Homes Home Supply Home Affordability Landscaping agents Credit Score Closing Costs Kitchen Renovations summer Charlotte County Punta Gorda Boca Grande downtown Sarasota architectural design historic art Renting vs. Buying Buying a Home "As Is" shopping shop local stores beaches Home Owners Associations downtown Historic home Home Inventories art museums museums galleries art gallery local art artists fall seasonal decor fall decor home decor Safety Tips Fixer Upper parks and recreation parks nature Find an Agent Insurance Policy spring music in the park tours venues Home Resolutions pets Open House Info Open House Questions Home Equity House Hunting Checklist Protect Your Home Weatherize Your Home Home Prices kitchen kitchen updates Market Conditions

Available Languages

English

April
3

Florida Dishes: Where to Go for Key Lime Pie

April 3rd, 2023 by Wagner Realty

Key Lime Pie

Key lime pie is Florida's official state pie. What better excuse to get some key lime goodness for yourself? Here are some of our real estate agents' favorite places to grab a slice of key lime pie around Sarasota.

Publix Super Market at Lakewood Ranch Town Center - 8330 Market St., Bradenton, FL 34202
It may not be the most unique destination on this list, but the Publix grocery store near our Bradenton homes for sale always has delicious key lime pies available for their customers. Their bakery offers original and mango-flavored key lime pies in full-size and mini versions. Customers are asked to order their pie by phone at least 24 hours before their desired pickup time to help the store get their treat ready for them.
Detwiler's Farm Market - 6100 N. Lockwood Ridge Rd., Sarasota, FL 34243
Detwiler's Farm Market has been run by the same Sarasota family since it first opened in the late '90s. They make a delicious key lime pie based on the home recipes of Mrs. Detwiler, the wife of the store's founder. Every pie is freshly baked and made from natural ingredients to create a beloved treat.
Caribbean Pie Company – 2245 Bee Ridge Rd., Sarasota, FL 34239
The Caribbean Pie Company is undoubtedly one of the best places for true key lime lovers to get their pie fix. In addition to their classic key lime pie, they also offer chocolate-covered key lime pie slices and key lime pie bites (tiny squares of pie capped with chocolate drizzle). They even carry a tropical fruit version of the treat that augments the tangy lime flavors with fresh raspberry, guava, and mango.
Floribbean Flo's - 7642 Tamiami Trail S, Sarasota, FL 34231
Floribbean Flo's is a small Caribbean-style bakery famous for their delectable key lime pie. You can pick up a whole pie to take home or indulge in one of their Chocolate Covered Key Lime Pie on a Stick treats right in the store. If you live close to our Sarasota homes for sale, you can even get these goodies delivered right to your door.
Yoder's Restaurant - 3434 Bahia Vista Street, Sarasota, FL 34239
Yoder's Restaurant is one of the most popular attractions in Yoder's Amish Village, a showcase run by members of Sarasota's Amish community. Their commitment to making food the old-fashioned way is a big part of what makes their Florida Key Lime Pie so good. Each slice combines the creamy lime filling with the warm toasted notes of the graham cracker crust to create an unforgettable, comforting dessert. You can stop by for a slice or order a whole pie to go—just make sure you place that order at least one business day before your pick-up date.
Der Dutchman - 3713 Bahia Vista St., Sarasota, FL 34232
Der Dutchman is another culinary gem run by members of the Amish community. Their Key Lime Pie is part of their standard fruit pie lineup and is one of their most popular dessert items year-round. You can visit the Der Dutchman bakery anytime between Monday and Saturday (6 a.m. to 8 p.m.) to pick up a pie to go or order a slice after a hearty meal at their dine-in restaurant.

Key lime pie is just one of the many goodies you'll have easy access to in Sarasota. Contact us today to learn more about how our real estate agents can help you settle down in this cozy community on Florida's western shoreline.

Categories: Sarasota-Manatee

Tags: Sarasota, FL, Restaurants, Dining, Bradenton FL, Bradenton Beach FL, Bradenton, FL, Local businesses, Sarasota County, downtown Sarasota

Related Markets: Bradenton, Bradenton Beach, Sarasota

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 03/02/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 03/02/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Mon 03/02/2026 3:58:56 PM EST) or Stellar MLS (last updated Mon 03/02/2026 3:46:11 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Wagner Realty may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Florida Dishes: Where to Go for Key Lime Pie

Contact Sherry

Login to My Homefinder

We have detected that you have cookies disabled.